- 1986
- Administrative - Stephen Priselac
- Public Service - Paul Agate
- Scholastic - Tracy Rose
- Scholarly - Nathan Viswanathan
- Teaching - Evelyn Pluhar
- 1987
- Administrative - Dennis Nurkiewicz
- Public Service - David Meredith
- Scholastic - Harold Pritts
- Scholarly - J. R. Simons
- Support - Library Staff - Geraldine Dorobish, Barbara Solesky, Rita Herring, Connie Diehl
- Teaching - Dennis Brestensky
- 1988
- Administrative - Lolita Sharp
- Public Service - Louis Ridgley
- Scholastic - Sharon Shearer
- Scholarly - Evelyn Pluhar
- Support - Tech Services
- Teaching - Albert Skomra
- 1989
- Administrative - Kent Crossland
- Public Service - Doris Coldren
- Scholarly - James Crawford
- Support - Larry Belan
- Teching - James Crawford
- 1990
- Administrative - Ted Mellors, Margaret Triplett
- Public Service - Howard Dantzler
- Scholastic - Kellie Pireaux
- Scholarly - David Meredith
- Support - Acad. Affairs - Harriet Galida, Jamie Onesi
- Teaching - Nathan Viswanathan
- 1991
- Administrative - Mary Baird
- Public Service - Margaret Frankenbery
- Scholastic - Michael Prinkey
- Scholarly - Evelyn Pluhar
- Support - Finance/Business - Joy Fike, Earla Knoyer
- Teaching - Rodger Henderson
- 1992
- Administrative - Willard Fuller
- Public Service - David Anderson
- Scholastic - Brenda Griglack
- Scholarly - Rodger Henderson
- Support - Patricia Hritz
- Teaching - Russell Filburn
- 1993
- Public Service - Nathan Viswanathan, Ellen Nesser
- Scholastic - Kevin Willis
- Scholarly - David DiPietro
- Support - Joyce Barnhart
- Teaching - Evelyn Pluhar
- 1994
- Public Service - Evelyn Hovanec
- Scholastic - Albert Bashur
- Scholarly - James Crawford
- Support - Tech Services - Paul Mihalko, Gerald Riggar, Robert Miller, Howard McGhee
- Teaching - Werner Pluhar
- 1995
- Administrative - Ellen Laun
- Public Service - Janet Gibson
- Scholastic - Karen Sidor
- Scholarly - Michael Comiskey
- Teaching - Charles Wall
- 1996
- Public Service - Geraldine Dorobish
- Scholastic - Alta Dezort
- Scholarly - Evelyn Pluhar
- Support - Barbara Solesky
- Teaching - Joshua Marvit
- 1997
- Scholastic - Robert Thomas
- Scholarly - Werner Pluhar
- Support - Acad. Affairs - Harriet Galida, Jamie Onesi
- Teaching - Evelyn Hovanec
- 1998
- Administrative - Bobby Salitrik
- Public Service - Wayne Port
- Scholastic - Charlotte Gordon
- Scholarly - Ivko Dimitric
- Support - Rita Gumbert
- Teaching - David Snyder
- 1999
- Administrative - Geraldine Dorobish
- Public Service - Joyce Barnhart
- Scholastic - Melanie Thomas
- Scholarly - Jerrold Hoeg
- Support - CE Team - Janet Jordan, Dianna Palmer, Tina Reed, Victor Yartz
- Teaching - Andrzej Gapinski
- 2000
- Administrative - Admissions Team - Louis Ridgley, Carolyn Johnson, Teri Sabatelli
- Public Service - David Meredith
- Scholastic - Carrie Brennsteiner
- Scholarly - Dennis Brestensky
- Support - Patricia Zebrasky
- Teaching - David Meredith
- Adjunct Teaching - Gregory Sefchik
- CE Non-Credit - Steven Todoric
- 2001
- Administrative - Kent A. Crossland
- Public Service - David A. DiPietro
- Scholastic - Lou Anne Krch
- Scholarly - C. Gib Prettyman
- Support - Tech Services - Robert Durany, Paul Mihalko, Gerald Riggar, Howard McGhee, Robert Miller
- Teaching - Richard D. Cupelli
- Adjunct Teaching - Werner S. Pluhar
- CE - Non-Credit - Thomas S. Brletic
- 2002
- Administrative - Willard L. Fuller
- Scholastic - Sandra E. Ryan
- Scholarly - Bradley C. Whitsel
- Support - Scott L. Williams
- Teaching - Beverly C. Peterson
- Adjunct Teaching - Patrick J. Daugherty
- CE Non-Credit - Mary Ann Walters
- 2003
- Administrative - Jane E. Witt
- Scholastic - Jeannine Kifus
- Scholarly - Richard A. Ball
- Support - Cheryl Haase-Duncan
- Teaching - Rodger C. Henderson
- CE Non-Credit - Kirk J. Hessler
- 2004
- Administrative - Theodore A. Mellors
- Public Service - Joan V. Clites and Jes Hutson
- Scholarly - Werner Pluhar
- Scholastic - James Shubert
- Support Services - Rita Gumbert
- Teaching - Kevin Maxwell
- Adjunct Teaching - Patricia Herring
- CE Non-Credit Teaching - Carmen Tringhese
- 2005
- Administrative Excellence - Joseph Segilia
- Public Service Excellence - Sharon Rendine
- Scholarly Excellence - Michael Comiskey
- Scholastic Excellence - Kathryn Blackburn
- Teaching Excellence - Nicole Hill-Perret
- Adjunct Teaching Excellence - Tom Rocks
- CE Teaching - Dennis Glaus
- Ellen Laun Advising Excellence - Jane Witt
- Rose Ann Williams Staff Mentoring - Joy Fike
- 2006
- Administrative Excellence - Geraldine Dorobish
- Public Service Excellence - Ted Mellors
- Scholastic Excellence - James Shubilla
- Scholarly Excellence - Judith Sturges
- Support Services Excellence - Janet Gibson
- Teaching Excellence - Elaine Barry
- Adjunct Teaching Excellence - Timothy L. Landy
- CE Non-Credit Teaching Excellence - Carl Nagy
- Ellen M. Laun Advising Excellence - Michelle Henrish
- Rose Ann Williams Staff Mentoring - Joyce Barnhart
- Barbara B. Solesky Staff Assistant Service Excellence - Jamie Onesi and Patty Zebrasky
- 2007
- Administrative Excellence - Dianna L. Palmer
- Scholastic Excellence - Eric Vinoverski
- Scholarly Excellence - Elaine Barry
- Support Services Excellence - Tech Services - James Burnsworth, Robert Durany, Vincent Gall, Robert Miller, Allen R. Tressler
- Teaching Excellence - Fred Adams
- Adjunct Teaching Excellence - Elaine Kelly
- Ellen M. Laun Advising Excellence - Melissa Miner
- Rose Ann Williams Staff Mentoring - Harriet Galida
- Barbara B. Solesky Staff Assistant Service Excellence - Cheryl Duncan
- 2008
- Public Service Excellence - C. Michael Comiskey
- Scholarly Excellence - Joseph M. Shostell
- Support Services Excellence - Joyce A. Barnhart
- Teaching Excellence - Danielle M. Mitchell
- Scholastic Excellence - Franklin La Cava
- Ellen M. Laun Advising Excellence Award - David B. Meredith
- Barbara B. Solesky Staff Assistant Excellence Award - Frank D. Georgiana
- 2009
- Administrative Excellence - Bobby Salitrik
- Scholarly Excellence - Donald Liddick
- Teaching Excellence - JoAnn Jankoski
- Adjunct Teaching Excellence - Werner Pluhar
- Scholastic Excellence - Alicia L. Daerr
- Ellen M. Laun Advising Excellence Award - William Gardner
- Barbara B. Solesky Staff Assistant Excellence Award - Sherry Scully
- 2010
- Administrative Excellence - Paula Congelio
- Public Service Excellence - Jo Ann Jankoski
- Scholarly Excellence - Jerrold Hoeg
- Support Services Excellence - Sherry Scully
- Teaching Excellence - Kevin Maxwell
- Adjunct Teaching Excellence - Sharon Harrold
- Scholastic Excellence - Jessica Smell
- Ellen M. Laun Advising Excellence Award - Kevin Maxwell
- Rose Ann Williams Staff Mentoring Excellence Award - Rita Gumbert
- Barbara B. Solesky Staff Assistant Excellence Award - Billie Jo Yuhaniak
- 2011
- Administrative Excellence – Rita Gumbert
- Scholarly Excellence – Joseph Shostell
- Support Services Excellence – The Financial Assistants Team: Earla Knoyer and Sharon Rendine
- Teaching Excellence – Janet Knott
- Adjunct Teaching Excellence – Shirley Dempsey
- The Ellen M. Laun Advising Excellence Award – Lawrence Hunchuck
- The Barbara B. Solesky Staff Assistant Excellence Award – Michelle Henrish